The Invisible surveillance tool in Every Coffee Shop & no, its not a camera

For years, a certain type of person has insisted that the walls have ears. That the government, corporations, or someone, could track your movements even without a phone being in your pocket. Most people dismissed this as paranoia, and said its the kind of thinking that belongs on reddit forums next to posts about chem trails.

Well, it turns out the paranoid were just early.

A team from Germany's Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) just demonstrated that standard Wi-Fi routers can identify individual people with near-perfect accuracy. And this is without those people carrying any devices at all. No smartphone in their pocket or smartwatch on their wrist. Just their bodies moving through wifi signals and radio waves that happen to be in the air around them.

If this sounds familiar, you might be thinking of that one Batman movie, The Dark Knight. In that film, Batman builds a surveillance system that turns every cell phone in Gotham into a sonar device, mapping the city in real time to locate the Joker. Lucius Fox, the man who built it, is so disturbed by what he's created that he threatens to resign. He told Bruce Wayne, "This is too much power for one person,". The film treated this technology as a moral line that shouldn't be crossed, it was a technology so invasive that even the hero using it for good couldn't justify its existence.

That was in 2008 and it was science fiction. Now, in 2025 it's a peer-reviewed paper.

A small interruption to say THANK YOU to our sponsor!

This mornings newsletter is made possible by Money.com

Have you always been kind of interested in investing but found it too intimidating (or just plain boring)? Yeah, we get it. Luckily, today’s brokers are a little less Wall Street and much more accessible. Online stockbrokers provide a much more user-friendly experience to buy and sell stocks—right from your couch. Money.com put together a list of the Best Online Stock Brokers to help you open your first account. Check it out!

Start investing

… okay now lets get back to the story ✌️

The technique exploits something called beam-forming feedback information, or BFI for short. Modern Wi-Fi devices constantly send these signals back to routers to optimize connection quality. And this data travels unencrypted, meaning that its readable or it can be seen by any device within range. What the KIT researchers discovered is that when a human body passes through these signals, it creates a unique disturbance pattern, almost like a fingerprint made of radio interference.

They plugged these patterns into a machine learning model and tested it with 197 subjects, the system identified individuals with almost 100% accuracy. It didn't matter how you walked and it didn't matter what angle you approached from. It didn't even matter if you were carrying bags or boxes. The radio waves saw through all of it and correctly identified the right person.

The systems to exploit this is already everywhere. Wi-Fi networks blanket homes, offices, restaurants, airports, subway stations. The researchers estimate this could become what they call "a nearly comprehensive surveillance infrastructure", one that's invisible and raises no suspicion.

Julian Todt, one of the researchers, put it plainly: "This technology turns every router into a potential means for surveillance."

And when you think about the applications, things get dark pretty quickly. In authoritarian states, this could track protesters without the mess of facial recognition cameras. Companies could monitor foot traffic patterns and identify repeat visitors. And unlike a security camera mounted on a wall, there's nothing to notice. No lens or red recording light, it just the same router that's been sitting in the corner for years.

Previous Wi-Fi sensing research required specialized hardware or access to the router itself. This new method needs neither. Any device that can receive Wi-Fi signals can potentially collect the data. The attack surface, is every connected device within range. So that includes your neighbor's laptop, a stranger's phone, and even the smart TV in the waiting room.

The researchers are now pushing for privacy protections in the upcoming IEEE 802.11bf Wi-Fi standard. Specifically, they want BFI data encrypted by default. Without that change, every router upgrade expands the potential surveillance grid.

Unfortunately, there's no consumer fix for this.. yet. And you can't opt out of walking through radio waves. Turning off your own devices does nothing because the imaging uses other people's devices. The only safe environments are the increasingly rare spaces with no Wi-Fi at all.

In The Dark Knight, Batman destroys the surveillance system after using it once, acknowledging it was too dangerous to exist. In reality, the infrastructure is already built into every coffee shop, office building, and home. The only question is who decides to turn it on, and whether we'll even know when they do.

So the tin foil hat guys got another “W” with this one.

We’ll keep you updated on new developments.

dontgetgot